You’ve got a buzzing Facebook post, a flood of comments, and a prize with someone’s name on it.
Now you just need a fair, fast way to pick that winner using a Facebook comment picker. If you’ve ever tried scrolling through hundreds of comments and “eyeballing” a name, you know it’s a mess. The good news: there are reliable, free Facebook comment picker tools that efficiently streamline your giveaways without draining your time or your budget.
I’ve tested and used a bunch of them—here’s what actually works, what’s free, and what to watch out for.
What Makes a Great Free Facebook Comment Picker
Before you spin the wheel on any tool, check it against a few must-haves. Not every “random comment picker” is built the same, and Facebook’s rules matter.
Key features to look for
Connects securely to Facebook: Look for tools that use Facebook Login (OAuth) and work with Pages you manage. This helps with compliance and accuracy.
Filters that matter: Deduplicate by user, include or exclude replies, and optionally filter by keyword if your rules require it.
Proof of fairness: A public winner URL, draw ID, or downloadable report goes a long way when followers ask, “Was this legit?”
Transparent limits: Free tools usually cap entries or daily draws. Make sure the cap isn’t lower than your comment count.
Privacy-minded: Reputable tools avoid scraping and follow Facebook’s Platform policies.
Policy and trust checkpoints
Follow Facebook’s promotions rules: You need to include eligibility, official rules, and a complete release of Facebook. Also clarify that your promotion isn’t sponsored or administered by Facebook. See Facebook Pages, Groups and Events Policies (Promotions section).
Understand API limits: Tools that fetch comments for Pages you manage typically rely on the Graph API and reviewed permissions. See Meta’s developer docs for comments endpoints and permissions: Meta Graph API.
Best Free Facebook Comment Picker Tools
Explore these Facebook comment picker options for seamless giveaways.
Below are the free options that consistently deliver. I’ll note what’s actually free, common limits, and when each one shines.
Simpliers — Facebook Comment Picker
Best for: Quick, legit draws on Page posts you manage, with clean proof links.
Simpliers offers a straightforward Facebook Comment Picker that connects via Facebook Login, pulls comments from a Page post you administer, and lets you filter duplicates or include replies. The interface is friendly and the proof page is neat—handy if you like transparency.
Free plan: Typically includes a limited number of draws or entries. Good enough for small to medium giveaways.
What I like: Clear UI, solid filtering, solid auditability. It feels purpose-built for social giveaways.
Watch-outs: Larger draws or advanced filters may require paid tiers. Always check current limits.
Try it: Simpliers Facebook Comment Picker and see current plan limits at Simpliers Pricing.
BlitzRocket — Facebook Comment Picker
Best for: Quick, transparent draws on public Facebook Page posts when your entry method is “comment to enter.”
BlitzRocket’s free Facebook Comment Picker lets you paste the URL of a public Page post, load the comments, apply optional keyword or duplicate-filters, and pick a fair winner in seconds. It’s built to finish contests cleanly—no manual scrolling, no spreadsheets—just a straightforward random draw you can explain and replay without drama.
Free plan: The picker is available as a free online tool. For simple comment-based giveaways, that’s usually all you need.
What I like: URL-based setup that pulls comments from a specific public Page post. Keyword and duplicate filters to enforce your entry rules. Fast, repeatable draws that are easy to announce live.
Watch-outs: Works with public Facebook Page posts; it won’t fetch comments from private profiles or closed groups.
Try it: Run a test draw with the BlitzRocket Facebook Comment Picker or browse the tool hub at blitzrocket.com/app/tools.
Woobox — Pick a Winner for Facebook
Best for: Brands that already use Woobox or want an all-in-one promo toolkit.
Woobox has been around for ages in the contest space. Its Facebook tools can import comments from posts on Pages you manage and pick winners randomly, with options to exclude duplicates and your Page.
Free plan: Historically includes limited entries or campaign actions. It’s workable for smaller giveaways, and you can upgrade when you outgrow it.
What I like: Reliable infrastructure, a familiar experience, and integrations for when you level up to bigger campaigns.
Watch-outs: Some features and larger entry volumes sit behind paid tiers.
Explore features: Woobox and check limits at Woobox Pricing.
AppSorteos — Sorteo de Comentarios en Facebook
Best for: Spanish-speaking pages and simple, fast draws.
AppSorteos provides a lightweight Facebook comment picker experience with a clear workflow: connect your Page, select a post, set filters, and pick winners. It’s popular in Spanish-speaking communities and does the basics well.
Free plan: Usually offers free draws with branding or limits. It’s perfectly fine for small promos.
What I like: Minimal friction, quick results, and accessible UI.
Watch-outs: Advanced options and higher caps often require paid upgrades.
Take a look: AppSorteos (navigate to the Facebook comments tool).
DIY Method — Spreadsheet + Randomizer (Wheel of Names or RANDOM.ORG)
Best for: One-off giveaways when you don’t want to authorize a tool or you’re dealing with a unique post type.
If your post is smaller or you’d rather not connect an app, you can go manual. It’s more hands-on, but it’s transparent and completely free.
Collect entries: Open your Facebook post, expand “All comments,” scroll to load them all, and copy the commenters’ names into a spreadsheet. Keep only one entry per person if your rules say so.
Clean your list: Remove your Page, duplicate names, and any ineligible entries based on your published rules.
Pick the winner:
Paste the final names into Wheel of Names and spin; or
Count total rows and use RANDOM.ORG to generate a random number, then match it to the row.
Show your work: Screenshot the list and the spin/number result, and post it for transparency.
Tip: For larger giveaways, the manual approach gets tedious. If your comment count creeps past a few hundred, a connected picker will save you time and reduce mistakes.
About CommentPicker.com (Status)
CommentPicker.com was a fan favorite for years, but their Facebook Comment Picker has been discontinued due to Facebook API and policy changes. They still offer pickers for other platforms, but not for Facebook. See their notice: CommentPicker.com.
Why mention it? You’ll still see old blog posts recommending it for Facebook. It’s better to use the tools above or go the DIY route.
How to Run a Fair Facebook Giveaway With a Comment Picker
A great tool won’t save a sloppy giveaway. Here’s the no-drama workflow I use.
Pre-launch checklist
Write clear rules: Eligibility, start/end time, how to enter (comment-based), how you’ll pick the winner, and how/when you’ll contact them.
Policy line: Include a release of Facebook and a statement that Facebook isn’t sponsoring or administering the giveaway. Source: Facebook Promotions Policy.
Keep entries simple: “Comment with X” is easier to verify than “comment + tag five friends.”
Drawing day: step-by-step
Confirm eligibility: Ensure the post met the entry deadline and disable new comments if necessary.
Pick your tool: For small posts, DIY works. For larger ones, use Simpliers or Woobox.
Set filters: Turn on “unique commenter” if your rules cap entries at one per person. Decide whether replies count.
Run the draw: Capture a screen recording or screenshots of the setup and result page.
Verify the winner: Check they met requirements (e.g., left a valid comment, regional rules).
Announce with proof: Post the winner on the original thread with your proof link or images. Keep it classy and transparent.
Post-draw essentials
Contact the winner via Page message or the communication channel your rules specify.
Document the result (proof URL, screenshots, date/time). It’s helpful if a dispute comes up.
Thank participants and tease the next giveaway. Momentum matters.
Sources and Documentation
Facebook promotions rules: Pages, Groups and Events Policies
Meta Graph API overview: Graph API Docs
Frequently Asked Questions About Facebook Comment Pickers
Looking for more tips? Check out our related blog post on running successful Facebook promotions.
Are free Facebook comment picker tools allowed by Facebook?
Yes—provided they access comments for Pages you manage using proper permissions and you run your promotion under Facebook’s policies. Always include the required release/disclaimer and follow local laws. Reference: Facebook Promotions Policy.
Can I pick a winner from a personal Facebook profile or a closed group?
Not reliably. Comment pickers are designed for Page posts you administer. Personal profiles and many groups have privacy restrictions that block tools from accessing comments.
How can I prevent duplicate or spam entries in Facebook comment giveaways?
Turn on “unique commenter” so each person gets one entry. If you’re dealing with spam, add a keyword rule (e.g., “Comment with the word ‘Summer’ to enter”) and filter for it. Then manually review the winner’s comment.
Can I count replies as entries?
Yes, if your rules say so and the tool supports it. Most pickers let you include replies or stick to top-level comments only. Be explicit in your rules to prevent confusion.
How can I prove that my Facebook comment giveaway draw was fair?
Use a tool that provides a public result page or draw ID (Simpliers and Woobox can help here), and record your screen while drawing. If you use a DIY method, share the final names list and the RANDOM.ORG result or wheel spin screenshot.
Are Facebook comment picker tools truly free to use?
They have free tiers, but with limits—like entry caps, daily draws, or branded proof pages. If your giveaways are frequent or big, you may outgrow the free plans and need a paid tier.
What should I do if a Facebook comment picker tool I used previously no longer works?
That happens when Facebook updates APIs or permissions. CommentPicker.com, for instance, no longer supports Facebook comments. Use Simpliers or Woobox, or fall back to the spreadsheet + randomizer method when in doubt.
Can Facebook comment picker tools filter by hashtags or mentions?
Usually you can filter by keywords, which covers hashtags. Mentions can be trickier and may not be a reliable requirement. Keep entry criteria simple for smoother verification.